Dark mode

[blechinger]

Long-time donator! First time caller. +1 more for dark mode. :)

I'll echo what Steve said back in April and other users have mentioned before then: this is an accessibility concern. I appreciate the deep work done on FreeFileSync to make it the best-in-class program it is and that you won't compromise that. I also appreciate this isn't a small request and that Microsoft is... Well... Microsoft. Even so I'd argue dark mode is an important feature.

Would exposing the UI elements to users for configuration be a reasonable alternative? The community could then design and share themes.

Much love!

[user74581]

I was able to get freefilesync with a dark version with wsl/ubuntu on windows.
It's not like freefilesync was natively in dark, but you could have freefilesync in a windows window and with a dark theme.

freefilesync inside a windows window. Launched from wsl under windows ✅

wsl should be disponible for free for win10 and win11, even with windows home versions (no need a win pro version) https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/wsl/

Installation steps wsl/freefilesync
1. install wsl with powershell as admin :

wsl --install


2. restart pc
3. install freefilesync from a wsl terminal :
- launch a standard terminal from windows, like cmd
- type wsl in this cmd terminal. This should open a new wsl terminal.
-then try install freefilesync in your wsl :

sudo apt install wget tar


then

wget https://freefilesync.org/download/FreeFileSync_13.0_Linux.tar.gz -O freefilesync.tar.gz


tar -xzf freefilesync.tar.gz


cd FreeFileSync


./FreeFileSync


sudo ln -s "$(pwd)/FreeFileSync" /usr/local/bin/freefilesync


4. ensure you have a dark theme for wsl
maybe

sudo apt install gnome-themes-standard


export GTK_THEME=Adwaita:dark


from a wsl terminal this could be enough for have a dark theme

5. then you should be able to launch freefilesync by typing freefilesync, from wsl terminal and have freefilesync with a dark version, on windows
It's maybe not perfect cause it's not like you have freefilesync natively dark, but at least you have freefilesync dark, from win10 or win11

[user74581]

I realized that

tar -xzf freefilesync.tar.gz
cd FreeFileSync
./FreeFileSync
sudo ln -s "$(pwd)/FreeFileSync" /usr/local/bin/freefilesync


is not ok
instead this, use

sudo apt install freefilesync


With freefilesync downloaded with wget, then tar -xvf freefilesync.tar
, then chmod +x FreeFileSync_13.8_Install.run, then ./FreeFileSync_13.8_Install.run i had freefilesync version 13.8 but not a dark version. But with freefilesync installed with "sudo apt install freefilesync", i had version 13.3 with dark mode
(I couldn't edit my previous post, so I created this one.)

[Sander Bouwhuis]

This is one of the last applications with an old-fashioned 'stare at the sun on my 4k monitor' interface. How is there no dark mode?!?

[moongate]

For me the lack of this feature personally has
- the stare at the sun problem
- the inability to make use of energy saving and hardware conservation on oled

When I was running into this I consulted this forum to understand if it was just me.
Turned out the number of threads and posts make up the top contributions in this forum even outnumbering many bug threads.

So I started advertising for this feature request and had good conversations with the voluntary moderators about it.
Being a donor already I made a couple of extra contributions specifically stating they are for dark mode.

All of this not even triggered a reaction by the product owner.
A statement not leaving us in the dark along the lines of
- its technically complicated
- I don't have time at the moment but maybe later
- etc

would have been nice but did not appear.

Instead update after update followed concentrating on many things but not the most asked feature from the userbase.

For myself I made the decision to move on and find an alternative solution.

[xCSxXenon]

All of this not even triggered a reaction by the product owner.
A statement not leaving us in the dark along the lines of
- its technically complicated
- I don't have time at the moment but maybe later
- etc

would have been nice but did not appear.

I mean, don't get me wrong, I also really want dark mode. But literally in the earlier pages of this thread you replied to, the developer has shared exactly what you claim to be missing...

[moongate]

All of this not even triggered a reaction by the product owner.
A statement not leaving us in the dark along the lines of
- its technically complicated
- I don't have time at the moment but maybe later
- etc

would have been nice but did not appear.

Instead update after update followed concentrating on many things but not the most asked feature from the userbase.

I have to correct myself on my comment, specifically on the above portion.

@xCSxXenon: I knew we could count on you and I would've been disappointed otherwise. As always, thank you for your suppport.

You refreshing my memory made me realize that the site admin did indeed comment on the technical limitations of being able to implement dark mode into a WIN32 application (simplky following the OS theme seems to be a 64Bit only feature on purpose) and the additional challenges of making this a seemless experience across the other platforms FFS supports.

I get it know that as long as FSS will be 32bit it cannot simply follow the OS theme.
So the request is wrong.

When will FSS move to 64bit? :-P

[SonicRings]

Couldn't FFS also just include its own dark theme, or even let us customize the element colours ourselves? The Soulseek-qt client is 32-bit and allows you to customize any colours you want, resulting in us being able to set our own dark mode ourselves. Just because FFS cannot use the Windows theme doesn't mean it can't have a dark mode.