supported file formats for detecting moved/renamed file

Get help for specific problems
Posts: 1
Joined: 28 Jun 2021

roh666

Hello, I cannot find an explicit list of file systems that support detecting moved/renamed files. also what if the source and target use different file systems? Is SMB breaking the function?

I tried these setups:
1. Master NTFS USB source HD sync via USB with NTFS internal drive - detecting worked, the comparing was very fast
2. Macbook with master USB drive formated HFS+ sync via SMB with NTFS windows machine - detecting did not work, comparing was very slow
3. Macbook with master USB drive formated HFS+ sync via SMB with BTRFS Synology NAS - detecting does not work, comparing is very slow

Currently I am on setup 3.I am renaming and organizing photos and I would really love the detect moved file function to work and improve the speed of comparison. Can you please advise any solution?
User avatar
Posts: 4867
Joined: 11 Jun 2019

xCSxXenon

It is based on file IDs, that is how FFS detects renames/moves. Both sides would only have to support it if you are using two-way sync. Unix filesystems don't support stable file IDs, which is why your Mac storage devices aren't working with it. Synology's filesystem/OS is also unix based, so doesn't work either. I used a Windows file share over SMB/NTFS and it works from what I can see